5 Signs You Need to Consult Email Reputation Specialist and Boost Deliverability

April 18, 2024
5 Signs You Need to Consult Email Reputation Specialist and Boost Deliverability

Imagine this: You've spent ages crafting an email campaign that's witty, informative, and bound to stir a reaction. You confidently hit send... then... silence. Not a single click or reply, just the eerie sound of tumbleweeds rolling through your inbox.

What happened to your masterpiece?

It likely fell victim to the dreaded spam folder. Every day, millions of emails end up there, casualties of a poor email reputation. Think of it like your online sending score - having a good one means your messages land safely in inboxes, while a bad one flags them as spam, never reaching their intended destination.

This article will outline five clear signs that it’s time to consult email reputation specialist. These experts are your secret weapon, helping you navigate the ever-changing world of email deliverability and ensuring your messages arrive where they should—in inboxes, not the spam graveyard.

5 Signs You Need to Consult Email Reputation Specialist

So, your email marketing efforts seem to be hitting a snag. You design compelling campaigns, but instead of the satisfying "ding" of new messages landing, crickets chirp back. This might signal a bigger issue: a tarnished email reputation.

Here are five unmistakable signs it's time to call in and consult email reputation specialist to get your campaigns back on track:

1. High Bounce Rates and Low Open Rates: Warning Signs of Email Deliverability Issues

Two critical metrics serve as sentinels for your email deliverability: bounce and open rates. Here's what they tell us:

- Bounce Rate: This metric indicates the percentage of emails that couldn't be delivered to a recipient's inbox. Imagine launching a marketing campaign with hundreds of colorful flyers, only to find some mailboxes overflowing, others with incorrect addresses, and a few designed to trap rogue flyers. These "undelivered" flyers mirror your bounce rate.


- Open Rate: This metric shows how many recipients actually opened your emails. It reflects the number of people who not only received your flyer but also looked at it.

Consistently high bounce rates coupled with low open rates paint a worrying picture. They suggest potential deliverability issues, meaning your emails might not reach their intended audience or fail to capture attention.

Consider the following potential culprits behind high bounce rates:

  • Inactive Email Lists: As people change jobs, forget logins, or move on, a list of outdated addresses can significantly inflate your bounce rate. It's crucial to regularly clean your list and remove inactive subscribers to maintain a healthy sender reputation.

  • Typos: Even a small typo in the email address field can cause your message to bounce back. Implementing double-checks and verification processes can minimize these errors.

  • Spam Traps: These deceptive email addresses, set up by email providers to catch spammers, can severely damage your reputation if you accidentally send emails to them. Practicing good list hygiene and ensuring your content is legitimate will help you steer clear of these traps.

Remember, while low open rates can sometimes stem from other causes, such as uninteresting subject lines, when combined with high bounce rates, they become a strong indicator of deliverability issues that need your attention.

2. Complaints and Unsubscribes on the Rise: A Sign Your Emails Have Gone Rogue

Imagine checking your inbox, excited to catch up on important messages. But instead, you're bombarded with a barrage of irrelevant emails. Clicking "unsubscribe" becomes a reflex action, a desperate attempt to escape the digital noise.

Unfortunately, this scenario might be how your email recipients feel if you notice increased unsubscribes and spam complaints. But why are these metrics such red flags?

Here's a closer look:

Your sender reputation acts like your online report card for email. High complaint and unsubscribe rates indicate serious issues.

Even if your emails technically get delivered, they might vanish into the spam folder, never reaching the recipient's inbox. Additionally, email providers might start treating your emails with more suspicion, filtering them more aggressively.

A surge in complaints can tarnish your brand image. People start associating your emails with unwanted noise, eroding the trust you've carefully built.

So, what can you do to turn things around? Consult email reputation specialist to diagnose the problem and develop a strategy to combat it. Here's a glimpse into their skillset:

Email Content and Practices Under the Microscope: They'll scrutinize your emails and sending habits to identify potential triggers for complaints. Are your subject lines misleading? Is your content irrelevant to your audience's needs? Are you bombarding them with emails every day?


Crafting a Complaint-Busting Strategy: Based on their findings, they can recommend solutions like personalizing your emails, segmenting your lists to target the right audience, or implementing permission-based marketing practices (where people explicitly opt-in to receive your emails).


Keeping Your Sender Reputation in Check: They act as guardians of your reputation, monitoring your complaint rates and working with email providers to improve your standing. Think of them as constantly polishing your online credit score for email.

By proactively addressing complaints and unsubscribes, you ensure your emails land where they belong - in inboxes, not the spam abyss. Remember, a healthy sender reputation paves the way for successful email marketing campaigns and a positive brand image.

3. You're Constantly Ending Up in Spam Folders

Why is the spam folder such a nightmare? Beyond the obvious frustration of unheard messages, it has serious consequences:

Invisibility: Landing in spam means your emails are essentially invisible, never getting a chance to spark interest or action from your target audience. It's like shouting into a void - your message simply can't reach its destination.


Reputation Damage: Repeatedly ending up in spam can make you appear like a digital spammer, eroding trust in your brand. People start associating your emails with unwanted junk mail, and that positive perception you've worked hard to build takes a hit.


Impact on Sales: The ultimate goal of email marketing is to drive sales or conversions. But if your emails are stuck in the spam folder, they can't influence purchasing decisions. It's akin to having a beautifully decorated store with locked doors—no customers can enter, and your sales suffer.

So, how do you escape the spam folder trap?

Use Spam Checker Tools: These tools act like eagle-eyed editors for your emails, scanning your content and highlighting potential red flags that might trigger spam filters, such as misleading subject lines, excessive use of exclamation points (!!), or overly large image attachments.


Consult Email Reputation Specialists: They are like codebreakers, deciphering the secret language of spam filters. They understand how these filters work and can identify areas where your emails might be getting flagged. With their expertise, they ensure your messages comply with the rules and avoid the spam folder altogether.

4. Sending Practices are Outdated or Non-Existent

Imagine hurtling blindfolded through a busy intersection, relying solely on instinct to avoid a collision. That's the email marketing equivalent of flying without a documented sending strategy. You might hit a few inboxes by chance, but you're more likely to end up in the spam or completely lost in the digital noise.

So, why is a sending strategy your email marketing lifeline? Think of it as your GPS, guiding you to your destination - engaged readers' inboxes. A documented strategy outlines best practices, sending frequency, and content guidelines explicitly tailored to your audience. Here's how a well-defined strategy can rescue your email marketing from the land of outdated practices:

Consistent Communication Builds Trust

Imagine your brand as a chatty friend—you wouldn't want their messages to sound completely different every time, right? Consistency builds trust and familiarity, making your audience more receptive to your updates. A documented strategy ensures your emails maintain a consistent voice and tone across all campaigns.


Targeted Audience, Targeted Engagement

The strategy should define who you're emailing and why. This allows you to craft content that resonates with specific audience segments. Think birthday cards—you wouldn't send the same one to your grandma and best friend, would you? The same goes for emails.

Targeted Content and Avoiding Spam Traps

Craft content that resonates with specific audience segments. Think birthday cards - personalized messages for different people. A documented strategy helps you define your target audience and ensures your emails adhere to best practices like permission-based marketing and clear unsubscribe options. This keeps your emails out of spam folders and improves your sender reputation, leading to higher engagement and click-through rates.

Finding the Sweet Spot and Data-Driven Decisions

Sending emails too frequently can be a turn-off, while infrequent messages might leave your audience forgetting you. A documented strategy helps you determine the optimal sending frequency for your audience, keeping your brand top-of-mind. This strategy also encourages tracking key metrics like open rates and click-through rates. Analyze this data to see what's working and refine your strategy for continuous improvement.

5. Lack of In-House Expertise

Investing significant resources into crafting compelling email campaigns is essential for successful marketing. However, your efforts may be in vain if these messages aren't reaching their intended audience. This could signal that your team lacks the in-house expertise necessary to navigate the intricate world of email deliverability.

Here's how partnering with a dedicated team of email reputation specialists can help:

Staying Ahead of the Curve: Email marketing regulations and best practices are constantly evolving. Without a dedicated team actively monitoring these shifts, your sending practices could quickly become outdated, impacting your ability to reach inboxes. Email reputation specialists act as industry watchdogs, ensuring your campaigns remain compliant and effective in this dynamic environment.


Demystifying Spam Filters: Spam filters function like complex algorithms with ever-changing rules. While many senders might struggle to interpret them, specialists possess the knowledge to identify potential red flags within your emails that might trigger a trip to the dreaded spam folder. They act as codebreakers, keeping your messages out of the junk and firmly in inboxes.

Turning Data into Actionable Insights: Successful email marketing thrives on data analysis. However, raw numbers can be overwhelming. Email reputation specialists are your data wizards. They analyze key metrics like open and click-through rates, translating them into actionable insights. With this knowledge, you can identify areas for improvement and continuously refine your strategy for better results.

Building a Stellar Sender Reputation: Think of your sender reputation as your online email personality. A good reputation ensures your messages get delivered, while a bad one relegates them to the spam abyss. Specialists can develop strategies to build and maintain a positive sender reputation, guaranteeing your emails reach the intended audience.

By partnering with email reputation specialists, you bridge the gap in your in-house knowledge and confidently navigate the complexities of email marketing. They become your allies, offering expertise to help you achieve your marketing goals.

Recognizing the signs that it is time to consult email reputation specialist is crucial for marketing success. This article explored these signs, highlighting the challenges of navigating email regulations, spam filters, and data analysis. By partnering with an expert, you ensure your emails reach inboxes, not the digital void. This investment in specialist support translates to a significant return on your marketing investment, maximizing the impact of your carefully crafted email campaigns.

Subscribe to our newsletter
Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.

Senders' Videos

Senders' Case Studies
SUSO Digital
Industry - Marketing & SEO
Project length - 2 years
Key result - Market growth, funnel saturation
Industry - Information Technology & Services
Project length - ongoing
Key result - New market penetration
Industry - Fintech
Project length - Ongoing
Key result - Safely scaled email outbound, moved off of Google, improved processes 

Founded by chef David Chang, Momofuku is a renowned culinary brand with a nation-wide presence, including restaurants and an online store with delicious goods. They ran into an issue with their email sending – high bounce rates and blocked sending.

With hundreds of thousands of people on their email lists eager to stay informed, and an impeccable reputation to uphold, Momofuku wanted to nip this problem in the bud quickly.

  • Momofuku reached out to Senders to run a diagnostic test on their sending infrastructure and find the root cause
  • Senders deliverability experts discovered an issue with their DMARC, which was preventing emails from being sent, as their WordPress wasn't aligned with their SPF
  • Senders provided the most effective solution helping Momofuku restore safe sending, and suggested next steps to ensure everything keeps running smoothly on their end
  • The client reported that Senders helped identify the problem and got them back on track 

Up for coffee with a health kick, sans the jitters? Try Everyday Dose – a brand on a mission to provide coffee lovers with a healthy alternative packed with all kinds of goodies. The Founder, Jack Savage, learned through personal experience that we needed an option that doesn’t lead to a slew of possible side-effects. That’s how this mushroom-based blend with nootropics and collagen protein came to be, helping boost focus, energy, and reduce stress in one go.

The Everyday Dose team prides itself on excellent customer support, in addition to their delicious set of products. So when they spotted DNS propagation issues setting up their customer experience platform, they reached out to Senders to find the best way to sort it out.

  • Senders deliverability experts confirmed the problem the team at Everyday Dose initially diagnosed
  • To enable healthy DNS propagation, the Senders team helped clean their DNS registrar of old DNS records that were causing issues with propagation
  • The client reported they were now able to set up their DNS correctly, enabling them to run their platform smoothly

While many follow the latest marketing fads, there are businesses that support their clients with impactful, data-driven strategies for long-haul success. One such business is Influence to Action, creating sales, marketing, and leadership strategies that provide lasting value to growth-centric B2B companies. Both their turnkey and “done with you” services are built to ensure measurable, tangible results, and come with ample flexibility to adapt to the company they’re meant to serve.

Naturally, they wanted to make sure their email sending infrastructure was set up correctly, to protect their reputation and successfully reach their recipients. Our deliverability team worked with the client’s team on:

  • Aligning the client’s three domains with Amazon to make sure they are compatible and optimized in order to integrate with Amazon’s system.
  • Setting up a proper DMARC policy to protect their domains against unauthorized use and phishing scams.
  • Enhancing email deliverability as well as security, so that each email sent from these domains can be properly authenticated and more likely to land in the right inbox.
  • As a result, the client can protect the reputation of their business and domains, while safely sending out their email campaigns.

Sometimes the sheer number of options of any product can be daunting – how on earth do you pick the right one? This is especially true with supplements, as we can find them just about anywhere, but we can rarely understand a third of the ingredients listed. Unlike most, Physician’s Choice provides supplements with pure, potent ingredients that work. No fillers or “proprietary” blends with unidentified ingredients. They do the research, so you don’t have to.

Integrity and transparency are part of their core values, so when their team ran into sending issues, they were referred to Senders.

  • The client’s team spotted issues with DMARC failures in Google Postmaster
  • The Senders deliverability team worked with the client to update the DMARC configuration to enable report collection
  • The client is now able to obtain detailed reports to diagnose the exact causes of the failures and prevent them in the future with proper DMARC setup
All Case Studies