How does email sender reputation work?

July 11, 2023
How does email sender reputation work?

Our private and business communication has become increasingly reliant on email, and ensuring the successful delivery of messages to recipients' inboxes has become a critical concern for individuals and businesses alike. However, simply hitting the "send" button does not guarantee that your email will reach its intended destination. And key factor that determines the fate of your messages in the vast expanse of the email universe is the email sender reputation.

Have you ever wondered how certain emails end up in the spam folder while others effortlessly land in the coveted inbox? The answer lies in the intricate workings of email sender reputation. In this article, we will delve into the fascinating realm of email deliverability and explore the factors that contribute to a sender's reputation, the measurement techniques employed, and the steps you can take to maintain a positive standing in the eyes of email service providers and recipients alike.

What is the email sender’s reputation?

Email sender reputation refers to the perceived trustworthiness and reliability of the sender's email infrastructure and practices. It is a measure of how well an email sender is regarded by email service providers (ESPs), mailbox providers, and spam filters. A positive sender reputation enhances the chances of successful email delivery, while a poor reputation can lead to emails being filtered as spam or blocked entirely.

Factors affecting email sender reputation

Several key factors influence an email sender’s reputation, and understanding them is crucial for maintaining a healthy reputation. Let's explore these factors:

1. IP Address Reputation

Each email is sent from an IP address associated with the sending server. The reputation of this IP address plays a significant role in determining the overall sender’s reputation. ISPs and mailbox providers maintain databases that track the behavior and history of IP addresses, assigning reputation scores based on various criteria such as email volume, complaint rates, and spam trap hits.

2. Domain Reputation

The reputation of the domain from which the emails are sent also contributes to the overall sender’s reputation. Domain reputation is evaluated based on factors such as authentication practices (e.g., SPF, DKIM, and DMARC), sending patterns, and the presence of spam or malware in the domain.

3. Content Reputation

The content of your emails can impact your sender’s reputation. Spam filters analyze email content, looking for indications of spammy or malicious intent. Certain phrases, excessive use of images, and misleading subject lines can trigger spam filters, damaging your reputation.

4. User Engagement Metrics

How recipients interact with your emails influences your sender’s reputation. Metrics such as open rates, click-through rates, and spam complaints are monitored by ISPs and mailbox providers. High engagement rates indicate a positive reputation, while low engagement or high complaint rates can lead to a deteriorating sender reputation.

By understanding these factors, email senders can take proactive steps to manage and improve their reputation, increasing the chances of their emails reaching the intended recipients' inboxes.

How email sender reputation is measured

To accurately gauge email sender reputation, a combination of techniques is employed, including the assessment of spam filters and email authentication, analysis of feedback loops and complaint rates, and the utilization of reputation monitoring tools and services.

Spam filters and email authentication

Spam filters are the gatekeepers of email deliverability. They assess incoming emails and make decisions based on various criteria, including sender reputation. Email authentication protocols, such as SPF (Sender Policy Framework), DKIM (DomainKeys Identified Mail), and DMARC (Domain-based Message Authentication, Reporting, and Conformance), play a crucial role in establishing sender legitimacy and trust.

SPF helps verify that the email is being sent from an authorized server, while DKIM adds a digital signature to the email to ensure message integrity. DMARC builds upon SPF and DKIM, allowing senders to specify how emails failing authentication should be handled. By implementing these authentication mechanisms, senders can improve their sender reputation and increase the chances of their emails reaching the inbox.

Feedback loops and complaint rates

Feedback loops enable recipients to report unwanted or unsolicited emails directly to the sender's ESP or mailbox provider. These reports are valuable sources of information that can impact sender’s reputation. Monitoring and promptly addressing feedback loop complaints can help mitigate issues that may harm the reputation and foster a positive sender-recipient relationship.

Complaint rates, measured as the percentage of recipients marking emails as spam, are closely monitored by ISPs and mailbox providers. Consistently high complaint rates signal poor email practices and can lead to a deteriorating sender reputation. Minimizing complaints through targeted and permission-based email campaigns is vital for maintaining a favorable reputation.

Reputation monitoring tools and services

Various reputation monitoring tools and services are available to help email senders assess their sender reputation. These tools provide insights into factors such as IP address reputation, domain reputation, and email deliverability metrics. By regularly monitoring their reputation scores and identifying potential issues, senders can take proactive steps to rectify problems and maintain a positive reputation.

It's important to note that email sender reputation is a dynamic and evolving metric. It can change based on sender behavior, recipient interactions, and evolving spam filtering algorithms. Regular monitoring and adjustment of email practices are crucial for maintaining a healthy sender reputation.

Tips for Maintaining a Good Email Sender Reputation:

Use proper email authentication

Implementing robust email authentication protocols, such as SPF, DKIM, and DMARC, is vital for maintaining a good sender reputation. These protocols not only establish your legitimacy as a sender but also help protect your domain from email spoofing and phishing attempts. Ensure that your email infrastructure is properly configured to include these authentication mechanisms, and regularly monitor their effectiveness.

Implement email list hygiene practices

Maintaining a clean and engaged email list is essential for a positive sender reputation. Regularly review and update your subscriber list, removing inactive or disengaged recipients. Monitor bounce rates and promptly remove invalid email addresses. Implement a double opt-in process to verify the legitimacy of new subscribers, preventing spam traps and bogus accounts from affecting your reputation.

Provide valuable and relevant content

Sending high-quality, valuable, and relevant content is not only beneficial for engaging your audience but also contributes to a positive sender reputation. Craft your emails carefully, ensuring they provide genuine value to recipients. Avoid using deceptive subject lines, overly promotional language, or excessive use of images that may trigger spam filters. Personalize your messages whenever possible to enhance recipient engagement.

Monitor and respond to feedback and complaints

Actively monitor feedback loops and take prompt action on any complaints received. Investigate the reasons behind the complaints and address them to prevent further issues. Make it easy for recipients to unsubscribe from your emails and honor opt-out requests promptly. By demonstrating a commitment to recipient preferences and feedback, you can build trust and maintain a positive sender reputation.

Regularly check and improve the sender score

Sender scores are proprietary metrics used by some ISPs and mailbox providers to assess sender reputation. Regularly check your sender score using reputable monitoring services or tools. If your score is low, identify the contributing factors and take corrective actions to improve it. Address any underlying issues that may be impacting your reputation, such as high bounce rates or spam complaints.

By following these tips, you can proactively manage and enhance your email sender reputation, improving deliverability and ensuring that your messages reach the intended recipients' inboxes.

Consequences of poor email sender reputation:

Email delivery issues

One of the primary consequences of a poor email sender reputation is compromised email deliverability. ISPs and mailbox providers employ sophisticated spam filters that actively evaluate the sender reputation to determine whether an email should be delivered to the inbox, filtered as spam, or blocked altogether. With a tarnished reputation, your emails may be consistently routed to spam folders or rejected outright, significantly reducing their chances of reaching the intended recipients.

Landing in spam folders

A negative sender reputation often leads to emails being flagged as spam. Even if your content is valuable and relevant, it may go unnoticed if it consistently ends up in recipients' spam folders. Landing in the spam folder not only reduces the visibility and impact of your messages but also diminishes the trust and credibility associated with your brand or personal identity.

Damage to brand reputation and customer trust

Emails sent from a sender with a poor reputation can negatively impact your brand's image and erode customer trust. Recipients may associate your brand with spam or untrustworthy practices, leading to a loss of credibility and potential business opportunities. Moreover, recipients who receive unwanted or irrelevant emails may unsubscribe or mark your messages as spam, further damaging your sender’s reputation and hindering future email communication.

Maintaining a positive email sender reputation is crucial to ensure that your emails consistently reach the inbox and foster positive engagement with your audience. By prioritizing reputation management and adhering to best practices, you can mitigate the potential consequences associated with a poor sender reputation.

In the world of email communication, actively managing your sender reputation is vital for successful message delivery. By understanding the factors influencing reputation, implementing measurement techniques like spam filters and feedback loops, and following actionable tips such as proper authentication and content creation, you can enhance deliverability and protect your brand's credibility. However, neglecting your sender reputation can lead to consequences like email delivery issues and damage to customer trust. Stay proactive and prioritize reputation management to optimize your email campaigns and achieve communication success. Thank you for joining us on this exploration of email sender reputation.

Subscribe to our newsletter
Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.

Senders' Videos

Senders' Case Studies
SUSO Digital
Industry - Marketing & SEO
Project length - 2 years
Key result - Market growth, funnel saturation
Industry - Information Technology & Services
Project length - ongoing
Key result - New market penetration
Industry - Fintech
Project length - Ongoing
Key result - Safely scaled email outbound, moved off of Google, improved processes 

Founded by chef David Chang, Momofuku is a renowned culinary brand with a nation-wide presence, including restaurants and an online store with delicious goods. They ran into an issue with their email sending – high bounce rates and blocked sending.

With hundreds of thousands of people on their email lists eager to stay informed, and an impeccable reputation to uphold, Momofuku wanted to nip this problem in the bud quickly.

  • Momofuku reached out to Senders to run a diagnostic test on their sending infrastructure and find the root cause
  • Senders deliverability experts discovered an issue with their DMARC, which was preventing emails from being sent, as their WordPress wasn't aligned with their SPF
  • Senders provided the most effective solution helping Momofuku restore safe sending, and suggested next steps to ensure everything keeps running smoothly on their end
  • The client reported that Senders helped identify the problem and got them back on track 

Up for coffee with a health kick, sans the jitters? Try Everyday Dose – a brand on a mission to provide coffee lovers with a healthy alternative packed with all kinds of goodies. The Founder, Jack Savage, learned through personal experience that we needed an option that doesn’t lead to a slew of possible side-effects. That’s how this mushroom-based blend with nootropics and collagen protein came to be, helping boost focus, energy, and reduce stress in one go.

The Everyday Dose team prides itself on excellent customer support, in addition to their delicious set of products. So when they spotted DNS propagation issues setting up their customer experience platform, they reached out to Senders to find the best way to sort it out.

  • Senders deliverability experts confirmed the problem the team at Everyday Dose initially diagnosed
  • To enable healthy DNS propagation, the Senders team helped clean their DNS registrar of old DNS records that were causing issues with propagation
  • The client reported they were now able to set up their DNS correctly, enabling them to run their platform smoothly

While many follow the latest marketing fads, there are businesses that support their clients with impactful, data-driven strategies for long-haul success. One such business is Influence to Action, creating sales, marketing, and leadership strategies that provide lasting value to growth-centric B2B companies. Both their turnkey and “done with you” services are built to ensure measurable, tangible results, and come with ample flexibility to adapt to the company they’re meant to serve.

Naturally, they wanted to make sure their email sending infrastructure was set up correctly, to protect their reputation and successfully reach their recipients. Our deliverability team worked with the client’s team on:

  • Aligning the client’s three domains with Amazon to make sure they are compatible and optimized in order to integrate with Amazon’s system.
  • Setting up a proper DMARC policy to protect their domains against unauthorized use and phishing scams.
  • Enhancing email deliverability as well as security, so that each email sent from these domains can be properly authenticated and more likely to land in the right inbox.
  • As a result, the client can protect the reputation of their business and domains, while safely sending out their email campaigns.

Sometimes the sheer number of options of any product can be daunting – how on earth do you pick the right one? This is especially true with supplements, as we can find them just about anywhere, but we can rarely understand a third of the ingredients listed. Unlike most, Physician’s Choice provides supplements with pure, potent ingredients that work. No fillers or “proprietary” blends with unidentified ingredients. They do the research, so you don’t have to.

Integrity and transparency are part of their core values, so when their team ran into sending issues, they were referred to Senders.

  • The client’s team spotted issues with DMARC failures in Google Postmaster
  • The Senders deliverability team worked with the client to update the DMARC configuration to enable report collection
  • The client is now able to obtain detailed reports to diagnose the exact causes of the failures and prevent them in the future with proper DMARC setup
All Case Studies